CSM8 Election Interviews: A Retrospective

 

And so, with last night’s interview featuring CCP Dolan, the Crossing Zebras CSM8 Election Interviews project is done and dusted. It’s a strange feeling now it’s all finished. Nothing like this had been attempted before in CSM history as far as I’m aware – to try and interview every single election candidate in a short, thirty minute format, asking pointed, difficult questions. Had I known just how much work would be involved, I’m not sure I’d have went for it but, once started, I had to follow through to the end. The thirty minute target existed for two reasons – firstly, I simply didn’t know how many candidates there would be so setting a realistic limit was needed to allow me to get through everyone. Secondly, it forces candidates to be concise and to the point so that listeners don’t have to listen to a bunch of preamble before getting to the good stuff. I only have so much time but I’m well aware that listeners only have so much time too. In my head, anything less than thirty minutes simply isn’t sufficient to get through the ‘who the candidate is / what their platform is / ask some questions’ format that would become the template.

Here are some numbers for you:

 

 

  • 36 interviews (including CCP Dolan and Apricot Baby)

 

 

  • A grand total time of 20 hours, 11 minutes and 40 seconds worth of podcasts

 

 

  • 30 of the final 35 candidates who made the CCP primary (86%)

 

 

  • Two individuals who didn’t turn up for booked interviews (ProGodLegend and Grand Admiral Simo-Hayha)

 

 

  • Around 110 hours worth of work (based on ~3 hours for each one) in 27 days (1st interview Mynnna 8th Feb, 36th interview CCP Dolan 2nd April with 27 days on an oil rig in the middle)

 

 

  • One very tired Xander

 

 

2YRTApq

I had set myself a target of getting 75% of the candidates who made the primary. That’s the number in which I felt the project becomes a relevant and comprehensive source for anyone looking for information on candidates. I ended up getting 86%. It goes without saying that I’d have loved to get 100% but it wasn’t to be. It certainly wasn’t for the lack of trying – candidates were evemailed, contacted in their Jita Park threads, grabbed on twitter and convoed in-game. The vast majority were incredibly receptive. I want to thank every single candidate who sat down to be interviewed by me. And I do mean everyone. Whether they interviewed well, badly or indifferently, each candidate who sat down with me gave the voters the ability to make decisions on who that person really is and that is a vital thing come election day.

It’s here that I should give a big thanks to Mynnna for going first. As the top CFC candidate, Mynnna is all but a lock for the election itself and I’d be shocked if he didn’t finish with the most votes when they are all counted at the end. By coming on first, he gave the project a legitimacy necessary when approaching other candidates afterwards. And the point wasn’t to be exclusive. The reason I had to start the project so early was that I wanted to remove any personal politics from the equation and give every single candidate who wanted it a platform. This meant I couldn’t wait until right before the election to get started as I wouldn’t then have the time to get through everyone. Of course, this meant taking certain individuals on their word that they would actually stand. For various disappointing reasons, not everyone I interviewed made the primary but that was a price that had to be paid to allow all the candidates to have an opportunity to be interviewed.

What quickly became apparent was that these interviews were going to be popular. Very popular. Way-beyond-what-Jeg-and-I-expected popular. Which is great news except for one wee problem – our old site and server infrastructure simply wasn’t capable of handling the traffic and bandwidth we were experiencing. Jeg worked his backside right off to get a new server setup and created a new site from scratch with a lot of complicated/terrible help from myself. The new site works very well and is the result of a very patient and industrious Jeg.

Other people started banging the drum but none more so than Poetic Stanziel. Poe has his detractors but he was a support throughout the project, keeping his readers posted on the interviews, creating some stunning artwork (one example of which you can see above) and posting regularly on Jita Park whenever the interviews were mentioned. It goes without saying that he is still an absolute fanny but at least he got this one right 😉

Lots of others have offered support too and everyone who posted something in the blog comments or in a reddit post or Jita Park or anywhere, thank you. It made it all worthwhile. A couple of people even deposited me some ISK! Huge shout out to Mr Blue and Blackhuey for that. I never did this for ISK and never asked anyone for any throughout the entire process. Not going to lie though, not been able to rat much of late. If you have some spare ISK kicking around looking for a good home, Xander Phoena sure would appreciate it!

I also want to thank CCP, particularly CCP Fozzie and CCP Dolan who were both a huge support throughout this. When this project was started, CCP knew nothing about it. I hadn’t approached them with the idea – this is simply something I wanted to do for the community. To hear Dolan tell me that CCP were all listening to the interviews and using my candidate list as the guide for who was standing was amazing. I hope when Dolan is working on his plan for making the CSM more visible to the player base he contacts those in the community who work so hard to bring content to voters. Both Dani and Alekseyev have done amazing work on Voices from the Void and Declarations of War respectively. Down The Pipe have also been keeping a close eye on all of the WH candidates.

Finally, a massive, massive thank you to my very patient and understanding wife. I am away from home for large chunks of time with work so when I am home, I try to spend as much time with my wife and baby as I can. Given I spent roughly 4 hours a day while home working on this was a huge strain on my time with them both but she understood this was something I wanted to do and once started, I had to see it through. And she is letting me go to Fanfest too! I am very lucky.

Whether I do this again or not next year, I don’t know. There’s lots to consider before we get to CSM9. For the moment, I am just glad to have this one out of the way and hope that I have contributed in some way to the CSM8 election. And remember, the best way you can repay me for the work I’ve done here is to go and vote. Not only go and vote but tell everyone else to go vote. Corpies, friends, randoms in local, anyone and everyone – tell them all to vote to make this a CSM which truly represents and speaks for the people.

Fly safe,

Xander

Tags: csm, csm8, election, xander

About the author

Xander Phoena

The good looking, funny, intelligent member of the team, Xander set up Crossing Zebras with Jeg in April 2012 mainly because he was talking too much about Eve on his other podcast. Playing the game for almost five years, Xander still has absolutely zero clue about how to actually play Eve but somehow still manages to talk a good game.


  • Two step

    You did an awesome job, and if I remember, I will send you some ISK as well

    • H

      Xander, you deserve some major kudos. Certainly from me, and I would hope that CCP will do so as well.

      That was huge. Well done, sir. Well done indeed 🙂

  • Mick Cooney

    From which interview was that Poetic graphic created?

    • I created that as the banner for the entire project.

      My plan was the create a poster for every candidate … but Xander was going through candidates too fast for me to keep up. So I eventually stopped.

      You can see the posters I did create here:

      http://imgur.com/a/R1wHn

  • Voter 315

    This is my first CSM. There is just no way I could have gotten up to speed on the candidates and the issues without your excellent interviews.

    Thank you most sincerely.

  • Dr Bob

    Thanks for all the effort, I have my own list of candidates to vote for now. There is no way I would feel this well informed without this podcast. Looking forward to the next CZ podcast!

  • Dude, seriously thank you for the effort and the content…fantastic. I am 100% going to vote now and before I may not have

  • Chitsa Jason

    You are the best!

  • Jeg_Elsker

    Just to add some information on the server aspects Xander mentions in his post:

    Since I started logging bandwidth on the old server up until we made the move to the new server

    28th March 2012 – 20th Feb 2013

    approximately 727.55 GB of data was transferred.. an average of about 60 Gig a month, or around 2 GB a day

    since we moved to the new server until now we have transferred 458.83 GB

    20th Feb to today is 42 days, meaning an AVERAGE of 10.9 GB a day, with a peak (so far) of 42 GB on the 28th March.

    remember, these are median values over the course of the day, we have seen at peak times traffic of about 60-70 Mb/sec going through the new server.. something that was simply not possible on the old setup!

  • Messiah Complex

    Monumental effort. Thank you.

  • BM

    I really appreciated this resource. As a new player, I wouldn’t have been as educated about the CSM without these interviews. Thanks!

  • Iloll

    Great effort, let me buy you a beer when you come to Iceland for fanfest.

    • xanderphoena

      Given the price of a beer out there, I’ll hold you to that 😉

      • Iloll

        I will do it with joy ^^

  • Thanks for doing all the work! Listened to all of them. Thanks!

  • Ali Aras

    Xander, thank you so so much for doing this. Your interview has helped my campaign a lot — it’s brought me to the attention of a wider audience, but it also pushed me to be a much better candidate, as before coming on to CZ I hadn’t been pressed on any weak parts of my platform.

    • xanderphoena

      Ari, if I had anything at all to do with you helping to hone your candidacy and platform, I’m delighted. You are a great candidate. I hope all the candidates see my tough questioning in a similar way 🙂

      • xanderphoena

        That’s very kind of you to say so. Glad you enjoyed them.

  • Reut Getz

    From a new player who is still learning the whos and hows of everything, these interviews have been a fantastic resource. Without them, I doubt me and my husband would be voting. Thank you.

    • xanderphoena

      Reut, that means a lot. If this project gets even a handful of people to vote who wouldn’t have otherwise, it makes it all worthwhile.

      • Dark Heartt

        Yeah I have to admit Xander, I probably would have only voted for Mangala Solaris and left it at that, but these interviews allowed me to do research on the people running while at work and helped me make an informed choice on who to vote for. Thank you for all of the hard work and I really hope you do this next year!

  • former -A-

    Well, even if I still consider you a traitor for going to the goons, I gotta say – very good work on the interviews.

    • xanderphoena

      That’s very kind of you to say so. Glad you enjoyed the interviews.

  • Niko Lorenzio

    These are absolutely incredible. They provide a much greater insight into the candidates then their little posts on the CSM page. I would like to give you my thanks for being aggressive and daring to ask the difficult question that any true journalist should be asking.

    • xanderphoena

      Niko, glad you enjoyed them and they gave you the insight you needed before voting. And thanks for the feedback – i really do appreciate it 🙂